How to Build a Lead Database of 3,800 Testable ASINs in 12 Weeks

Brian and Robin Joy Olson run the Builder’s Circle – a members-only community built to give online arbitrage sellers what they actually need: clear next steps, better buys, and the confidence to navigate the Amazon system. 

Inside, you get full access to their paid training archive plus ongoing series like Keepa Corner and Mastermind Minute that walk you through real Keepa charts, sourcing decisions, and current opportunities so you’ll always know what to look for and what to avoid. You’ll also plug into a focused group of OA sellers who are actively working the same business model so you’re never guessing or grinding alone. 

For a limited time only, membership is 50% off, so if you want Brian and Robin Joy’s systems and community in your corner, now is the time to join Builder’s Circle.

Third-party arbitrage sellers face a fundamental choice in how they approach sourcing. Some hunt. Some build. The difference in outcomes over time is dramatic.

This article breaks down exactly how one Amazon seller built a lead database of 3,800 testable ASINs in 12 weeks, what it actually cost him, and why this approach represents a paradigm shift in how modern arbitrage sellers think about sourcing.

The Scenario

Imagine you saw this ad:

FOR SALE: Lead database. 3,800 ASINs. Every single one sold at least 50 units in the last 30 days. Every single one has capital protection over the last 90 days. Every single one shows at least $5 potential gross profit after prep, inbound, and supply costs.

What would you pay for that?

The price is nothing. Because you can't buy it. But you can build it.

The 12-Week Case Study

One coaching client committed to building sourcing infrastructure instead of hunting for daily wins. Over 12 weeks, he spent approximately 20 hours per week on one activity: matching products from retail sites to ASINs on Amazon, then storing those matches in a lead database.

His tools were simple:

• ArbiSource, an automated sourcing tool at $69 per month

• A spreadsheet to store matches (upgraded later to a more robust system)

No heroics. No cape required. No teams of virtual assistants. Just one person doing the fundamentals consistently.

After 12 weeks: 45,000 matched products sitting in his database.

The Filter Moment

On a recent coaching call, he applied three filters in his lead management system. Just three.

These filters, known as the 3-Step Check from the PATH Frameworks, are designed to quickly identify which matches are worth testing:

1. Products that sold 50+ units in the last 30 days

2. Products with capital protection over the last 90 days

3. Products showing at least $5 potential gross profit

Out popped 3,800 testable ASINs.

That's approximately 8% of his total database. But 8% of something massive is still massive. And the 92% that didn't pass? They remain in the database. Market conditions change. Prices shift. Velocity fluctuates. What doesn't qualify today might qualify next month.

The Real Cost

Breaking down the actual investment:

• 20 hours per week for 12 weeks = 240 total hours

• ArbiSource at $69/month = approximately $207 over three months

• Database storage = free (spreadsheet) to moderate cost (dedicated systems)

• Filter application = 24 seconds

That's the price. Not thousands of dollars. Not a team of virtual assistants. Time and consistency.

Hunters vs. Builders

This case study illustrates the fundamental difference between two approaches to Amazon arbitrage sourcing.

Hunters wake up every day starting from zero. They search, they scan, they hope something shows up. When they find a winner, they celebrate. Then they wake up the next day and repeat the process. Every hour that doesn't produce an immediate purchase is lost.

Builders spend the same hours differently. They're constructing infrastructure. Every match goes into the database. Every hour of work compounds on previous hours. The database grows whether individual products work out or not.

The builder's math works differently:

• 240 hours invested

• 45,000 matches produced

• 3,800 testable ASINs after filtering

• 16 testable ASINs per hour of work invested

These aren't leads. These are testable ASINs. Products that already passed rigorous filters. Products ready to test.

What Changes After Building

When you have 3,800 testable ASINs sitting in a database, several things shift:

The pressure disappears. That anxiety of needing to find something today evaporates. The question shifts from "Can I find opportunity?" to "Which opportunity should I pursue first?"

Sourcing becomes surgical. Instead of wandering around online hoping to spot something, you filter for products at specific retailers and shop knowing exactly what you're looking for. The database tells you what to find. You go order it.

Testing confidence increases. When you have 3,800 options, one failed test is just data. Move to the next one.

Breaks don't destroy momentum. The database holds your progress even when life gets busy. We wouldn't advise stepping away from sourcing for extended periods - this should be an ongoing activity that keeps your database growing, potentially at a slower pace. But in a pinch, the database waits.

A Shortcut to Building Your Lead Database

Everything above works, but only if you actually have leads to work with.

This is where a high-integrity lead list becomes a core asset in modern online arbitrage. Instead of starting from zero, you begin with vetted ASINs you can test, rabbit trail, and monitor as market conditions evolve.

Used this way, a lead list isn’t a shopping cart. It’s a time-compression tool that lets you skip starting from zero and build a usable lead bank in weeks instead of months, while still following the builder process outlined in this case study.

👉 See how FBA Lead List fits into the lead-building system outlined in this case study.

The Transformation Beyond Numbers

The most significant change isn't the 3,800 ASINs. It's the psychological transformation.

Watching this client's face when those filters produced results was revealing. His shoulders dropped. His breathing changed. For the first time in his Amazon journey, he wasn't chasing. He was choosing.

He described feeling like he was always behind before. Always scrambling. Always watching other sellers post wins while wondering what he was doing wrong. Now he experiences something different: calm.

The calm of a builder who finished the foundation and knows the structure will hold. The calm of someone who stopped gambling on daily luck and started investing in compounding assets.

Getting Started

Building a lead database requires:

1. An automated sourcing tool - Something that matches products to ASINs faster than manual searching

2. A storage system - Start simple with a spreadsheet, upgrade later

3. Dedicated time - Real, scheduled, protected time for consistent work

4. Clear filters - Criteria to identify which matches are worth testing

5. Patience - The transformation becomes visible when comparing day one to week 8

The first few weeks feel like filling a spreadsheet. The magic happens when you compare early results to later results. Like body transformation photos, the day-to-day change is invisible, but the before-and-after comparison is mind-blowing.

The Bottom Line

You can have whatever world you want. But you have to build it.

What would you pay for a database of 3,800 proven, profitable ASINs?

The answer is: 12 weeks of consistency.

Are you willing to be a builder?

About the Authors: Brian and Robin Joy Olson coach Amazon FBA arbitrage sellers, helping them build sustainable businesses through systematic approaches to sourcing, compliance, and operational challenges. Learn more at OfficialOlsons.com.

Ready to build with a community that gets it? The Builders Circle is where modern arbitrage sellers come together to learn, grow, and keep building through the messy middle. Come join us at officialolsons.substack.com